Look, I’ve lived in Pasco County my whole life, and I’ve eaten my weight in pizza probably three times over by now. I’ve sat through the tourist trap spots, the chains that opened and closed before anyone noticed, and the hidden gems tucked behind strip malls on US-19 that nobody talks about enough. So let me just tell you straight — here’s where you actually want to go for pizza in Pasco County.
—
Vinny D’s Pizza & Soda in New Port Richey
If you haven’t been to Vinny D’s, I honestly don’t know what you’ve been doing with your weekends. This spot on Congress Street in New Port Richey is the real deal — a takeout-focused pizza joint that locals swear by. The crust has that slight char on the bottom that tells you they know what they’re doing, and the sauce tastes like someone’s grandmother made it on a Sunday morning — not that jarred stuff. They’ve been around long enough to have regulars who genuinely get upset if the specials change.
Insider tip: Go on a Thursday evening for the shortest wait on your order. The weekend crowds around downtown New Port Richey get thick, especially if there’s a Downtown New Port Richey event going on along the riverfront area. Thursday you can call ahead, swing by, and be in and out without a hassle.
Parking situation: There’s a small lot on site, and street parking nearby is usually manageable on weekdays. If you’re going on a Friday or Saturday night when Sims Park events are happening, just budget extra time.
Best For: Takeout pizza nights and anyone who appreciates a proper New York-style slice without having to drive to Tampa.
—
Sergio’s Restaurant & Pizzeria in Zephyrhills
Zephyrhills folks, don’t even try to argue with me on this one. Sergio’s has been feeding this town for years and there’s a reason the parking lot gets full on Friday nights. This is your classic, generous-with-the-cheese Italian pizzeria on State Road 54. The kind of place where you walk in and immediately feel like a regular even if it’s your first time.
The garlic knots here deserve their own paragraph. Genuinely. They come out soft and buttery with just the right amount of garlic, and if you don’t order them as an appetizer you’re making a mistake I can’t help you recover from.
Best time to visit: Lunch on a weekday is when you’ll get the fastest service and the freshest lunch specials. If you’re coming for dinner, aim for before 6:30 PM because Zephyrhills dinner rush is a real thing — the town runs on early schedules, and the families with kids come rolling in right around 5:30.
Parking: Lot right in front, generally no issues. This is Zephyrhills — parking is rarely a problem.
Best For: Families, big groups, anyone who wants a mountain of food for a reasonable price.
—
900 Degrees Woodfired Pizza in Wesley Chapel
Wesley Chapel has exploded in growth over the last decade and with it came some genuinely solid restaurant options. 900 Degrees is one that actually earned its reputation the right way — through consistently good food and not just riding the wave of the new development money that flooded the area.
The wood-fired oven is not a gimmick here. You can taste the difference in the crust immediately. It’s got this slightly crispy exterior with a chewy interior that holds up under the toppings instead of getting soggy halfway through your second slice. I’m particular about pizza structure. This pizza has structural integrity.
Their specialty pies are where they really shine. Don’t just order a plain cheese — let them show off a little. A white pizza with fresh ricotta is something I think about more than I should probably admit.
Insider tip: Wesley Chapel is still figuring out its traffic patterns with all the new construction. If you’re coming from Zephyrhills Road or heading from the Wiregrass area during afternoon rush, leave earlier than you think you need to. The SR-56 corridor can back up badly from about 4:30 to 6:30 PM on weekdays.
Parking: Ample parking in the shopping center lot. No stress there.
Best For: The newer Pasco residents who want something a step above casual, and for anyone who has family visiting from out of town and wants to impress them.
—
Pizza Chef in Holiday
Holiday gets overlooked a lot. People driving through on US-19 don’t stop because US-19 through that stretch isn’t exactly what you’d call inviting. But Pizza Chef is the kind of neighborhood spot that the regulars are almost protective of — they don’t want it to get too popular and lose that intimate feel.
It’s small. The seating is tight. The menu isn’t overwhelming. And somehow that’s exactly right. The pizza is thick and loaded and feels like something you’d eat sitting around someone’s kitchen table on a Saturday night watching football. The staff has known most of their customers by name for years, and if you go enough times, they’ll know yours too.
Best time to visit: Early evening on a weekday. This spot fills up fast on weekends and it’s small enough that a full house means waiting outside. Worth it, but plan accordingly.
Parking: Small lot attached, street parking available. US-19 traffic noise is just part of the ambiance — embrace it.
Best For: Solo diners, longtime locals, anyone who wants to feel like a regular from their very first visit.
—
NY Times Square Pizzeria in Land O’ Lakes
Land O’ Lakes has been growing almost as fast as Wesley Chapel, and NY Times Square Pizzeria, tucked into the Village Lakes Shopping Center, has become a steady neighborhood favorite. Friday nights here are practically a neighborhood event. You’ll see little league teams celebrating, people stopping in after events at nearby sports fields, and families who have been coming here since their kids were small enough to need a booster seat.
The calzones here are almost as talked about as the pizza itself. Enormous, stuffed past the point of reason, served with a side of marinara that gets its own dedicated dipping moment. If you’re going for the calzone, just know: you probably won’t finish it in one sitting and that’s completely fine.
Insider tip: Call ahead or check wait times before you show up on a Friday night. I’ve shown up without thinking and waited 45 minutes. I’ve also called 30 minutes before leaving the house and walked right to a table. Be the person who calls. They’re closed Sundays, so don’t plan a Sunday night run here.
Parking: Shopping plaza parking, generally enough spots but the Friday dinner rush can make it competitive. Circle once before giving up — turnover is steady.
Best For: Post-game celebrations, family dinners, anyone who wants truly generous portion sizes.
—
A Few General Tips for Pizza Hunting in Pasco
Pasco County is big — it stretches from the Gulf Coast all the way inland, and the culture shifts noticeably between coastal New Port Richey and inland Zephyrhills. What works for one area doesn’t always translate to another, and that’s actually part of what makes eating your way around the county interesting.
Cash is still welcomed and sometimes preferred at the smaller spots. Keep some on you. Also, don’t sleep on the lunch specials — several places on this list have weekday lunch deals that will make you feel like you got away with something.
And finally: if you see a line outside a small pizza place in Pasco County, that line is information. Get in it.
—
FAQ
Q: Are there any good gluten-free pizza options in Pasco County?
A: A few places on this list do offer gluten-free crust options. Always call ahead and ask specifically about their preparation process if you have a serious sensitivity, because smaller kitchens don’t always have dedicated prep surfaces and cross-contamination is a real consideration.
Q: What’s the best area in Pasco County for a pizza dinner out if I want a full evening experience?
A: Downtown New Port Richey is genuinely your best bet for making a full evening of it. You can grab pizza, then walk along the riverfront at Sims Park, check out what’s happening at the Richey Suncoast Theatre, and it feels like an actual night out rather than just driving to a strip mall. The Main Street area has improved a lot over the last several years.
Q: Do these restaurants deliver, or is Pasco County mostly a pick-up and dine-in pizza culture?
A: Honest answer — it’s mixed. Some of these spots use the third-party delivery apps, but delivery coverage in parts of Pasco is inconsistent, so it’s always worth calling ahead to confirm before you count on delivery arriving quickly. When in doubt, picking up in person is the more reliable option, and you get to enjoy the pizza at its freshest.